What's the Best Timing for Direct Mail Retargeting?

Visual illustrating key timing strategies for direct mail retargeting campaigns, highlighting the importance of reaching potential customers at optimal moments for increased engagement and conversions

What’s the Best Timing for Direct Mail Retargeting?

The importance of direct mail retargeting in your marketing strategy is clear. But how do you know when to send direct mail?

Timing is everything

The end game of every direct mail marketing campaign is conversions. So, an important part of the marketing mix is driving traffic to your website.

Direct mail retargeting allows you to send direct mail to those who are highly likely to convert. It’s just as important to understand who not to mail to because they will convert anyway, maximizing incremental ROI.

Programmatic direct mail takes retargeting a step further. Instead of batching out mass mailings to a broad audience, programmatic direct mail uses data-driven automation. Companies can send personalized printed materials to retarget specific individuals in response to their online behavior.

“Programmatic” refers to the use of software and algorithms to automate buying, placement, and optimization of digital ads, so you can target specific audiences in real-time, based on their online behavior and interests.

The process begins with collecting and analyzing data from your digital marketing efforts: website visits, email interactions, social media engagements, etc. We use this data to create customer profiles, identifying those with a high likelihood to make a purchase.

Once these prospects are identified, a direct mail piece is generated, with the goal to create a perfectly timed reminder to draw them back for a purchase.

The power of immediacy

With retargeted direct mail, a mail piece can be sent within 12-24 hours of a digital interaction. And according to the National Postal Forum, when that mail is hyper-targeted and sent while a brand or product is still top of mind, marketers saw a 300-400% lift in conversion rates when targeting cart abandoners. Additionally, 65% of marketers reported an increase in website traffic and 47% reported an increase in conversions.

National jewelry retailer Gorjana, an early adopter of programmatic direct mail, has achieved over triple-digit incremental growth on both response rate and lift with retargeting postcard campaigns.

Gorjana CMO Elton Graham says, “From an ROI perspective, direct mail continues to be one of our strongest channels and gets us directly inside prospects’ homes.”

For more findings on the power of direct mail, download The Evolution of Direct Mail in a ROAS-Driven World >

Published on: 05/02/24

Recent Articles

The Brand Echo Effect: How Direct Mail Strengthens Multi-Channel Marketing

Most consumers won't remember the first time they saw your brand. Or the second. But by the third or fourth touchpoint — a postcard, an Instagram post or a retargeting ad — something clicks. The name feels familiar, and the brand feels trustworthy. That’s not an accident. Meet direct marketing’s brand echo effect Repeated, recognizable…

Why Direct Mail Deserves a Bigger Role in Your Marketing Mix

Inboxes are a wall of competing subject lines, all vying for a click. No wonder more of consumers say they feel overwhelmed by digital marketing, tuning out messages before they ever get a fair chance. The mailbox tells a different story, as 84% of consumers open and read direct mail the same day it arrives.…

AI in Direct Mail: 3 Ways AI Is Improving Campaign Performance

For decades, direct mail success came down to educated guesses. Mail the right list, hope the offer lands, wait weeks for results, then adjust for next time. That’s changing fast. Three in four marketers now use AI in some form, whether that's personalizing content, forecasting campaign performance or generating visuals. It’s compressing months of testing…